I haven't read all these posts, so, if it's been stated before, then I for one, voice the opinion that:
1. I really love carving because it IS different than what everyone else is doing and provides me a s#$%load of grins.
2. I couldn't care less what other people think about my carving, technique, or style. I ask other carvers for their input on how to sharpen my lines and, therefore, jack up the thrill factor. (If I cared what others thought, I would have quit a long time ago.).
3. I WANT carving to be a personal expression of freedom, skill and joy. I only speak for myself that you'll never see me in any "synchronized carving" event!
4. I've personally watched hardbooters running great lines since '97, and I'm sure they've existed before that. I'm not aware of any "recruiting" or "advertising" to increase our ranks.. aren't we slowly growing now? (SES is growing, isn't it??). Why are (some) people crying "ohhh, we have to do more to grow our sport, or board manufacturers will stop development (or whatever opinion was expressed...)?? Cry me a river.. the people who are interested in carving will pursue it.. the people who aren't, won't.
5. Sorry that there isn't an "newbie carver outreach program" ("newcoup"??). Ask, read what's available, approach (most) any carver and you'll find a friendly, helpful, passionate individual willing to share what he/she can... keep the advice that works for you, forget the stuff that doesn't. (There is PLENNTTY of evidence here on BOL that proves many here love to help/share their insights..).
I'm very happy as a learning novice and hope the learning curve takes 20 years!! Ahh, the joy of discovery...
(oh, and because I still flail down the mountain, NOBODY, and I mean NOBODY asks me for any advice! --Although I'd be happy to share!!;)