"Where you ride makes a lot of difference in the answer to this question" -- BigwaveDave is on the right track but there still is that ultimate board.
Bryan,
A poll would work.
Many answered with boards they had. That's great. But not what I was looking for. I wanted to see what characteristics most guys are looking for if they get a carving board.
For me, the ultimate carving board would have impeccable performance on icy and firm surfaces and it wouldn't be metal or have a need for a plate. Its quality would sit side by side with it's performance. After a few hundred days of riding this ultimate board, it would still ride like it was new and barely have a scratch on it. There wouldnt be your typical top sheet chunks taken out, etc. Its base would be almost gouge proof and have a high resistance to base burn/oxidation from man made old snow. There would be no graphics on the base or top. The edges would be tempered harder than the average soft edge..maybe a little harder to hand file but lasting longer.
Quality and performance are the two characteristics I would look for. It must also have a very high fun factor. Would you want to spend almost 2k on a deck and have rusty inserts? Been there, kind of sucks.
The ultimate board would almost have a cult following. The ultimate board would be somewhat "magical" allowing the rider to pull off turns he/she once before dreamed of.
Where did free carving go? Did it sell itself to racing? The ultimate board wouldn't be a good race board.
Maybe some day about 6 of the top manufacturers could collaborate and make the ultimate board because right now not one single one has it. I mean no offense by that statement because there certainly are some good/great product out there. But they are not the ultimate. We may see something come out of Europe, but I dont have any timeline or details for that at this time.