All, I think I am the posterchild for how to do things right (at least with regards to trying to join the ranks of carvers)! I have been snowboarding for years (mostly skidding - with accidental carves). I stumbled across bomberonline, did the instructor search, found Phil Bowman in PA at Roundtop, which is closest to me. Called and got a lesson, pretty much following most of what bomber online suggested. I had a lot of trepidation that this was going to be a big waste of time has most snowboarding instruction seems to be sort of ad-hoc and not really that useful. His instruction, on the other hand, has totally re-invented my boarding. He knows his stuff! I spent 2 hours with him and am on the journey to carving. This was the best 2 hours of snowboarding instruction I have ever received. Slice and dice! He corrected some of my many errors, managed to convey to me what I was supposed to be doing and presto, carving (not pretty and not perfect) but woohoo it is fun. He also gave me realistic drills that I can and am doing at home. He also managed to beat into my head that I can't simply stick hardboots and step-in bindings on my current nidecker megalight62 and expect that to necessarily work. The painful truth is that I need 2 setups, 1 for my softboots and a separate alpine setup $$$$ - oh well. At least temporarily, I will work on improving my current carving technique with my softboot setup.
Anyway anyone who wants instruction in carving - I strongly endorse Phil - and no I don't get anything for this other than spreading the truth.
Rich S.